For independent candidate Dr. Peter Entwistle, all politics is about health

By on April 25, 2017
Dr. Peter Entwistle says when healthcare is more than half of all provincial spending and when other issues all have a health aspect, a doctor with his background can help to remedy the system as MLA . Pictured here, he examines the X-Ray of Penticton Vees player Ty Amonte, taking a short break from in interview about his decision to run as an independent candidate in the May 9 provincial election. (Richard McGuire photo)

Dr. Peter Entwistle says when healthcare is more than half of all provincial spending and when other issues all have a health aspect, a doctor with his background can help to remedy the system as MLA. Pictured here, he examines the X-Ray of Penticton Vees player Ty Amonte, taking a short break from in interview about his decision to run as an independent candidate in the May 9 provincial election. (Richard McGuire photo)

For independent candidate Dr. Peter Entwistle, the May 9 provincial election is all about healthcare.

Not only is healthcare the most important issue – accounting for more than half the provincial budget – but every other issue is tied to health and well-being, he says.

“Virtually everything in life comes back to health,” said the 53-year-old Oliver physician in an interview at the South Okanagan General Hospital (SOGH) emergency room. “It works both ways. You can’t have happiness and well-being without your health. And when you have poor health, that affects your finances and your ability to work, so virtually wherever the provincial government has an interest, then there’s a health aspect.”

Even issues such as the proposed national park reserve, housing or the taxation system involve health in some way, he said.

“When I talk about health, I don’t mean pills, tablets and operations,” said Entwistle. “I look at the broader sense of holistic well-being.”

Independent candidates are very seldom elected and the few that are typically get relegated to a back corner Legislature seat, rarely given a chance to speak.

But Enwistle is both confident of victory and believes he can best represent Boundary-Similkameen as an independent voice, unconstrained by party whips.

“There’s no point in doing it if you’re not running to win,” says the soft-spoken doctor after a brief interruption to view a Penticton Vees player’s X-ray. “I could have just stood and shouted from the sidelines. That would have been easy for me. But I really believe that I have the ability to make a difference.”

Entwistle says he’s confident because of the feedback he’s received from all ends of the riding.

“Virtually everyone I’m speaking to says they’re going to vote for me,” he says. “Obviously it’s skewed, but it’s not just within the communities where I think I’ll do well. When I go out to Princeton, even in Grand Forks, people have heard of what I’m doing and I’m getting positive messages.”

Even people who normally vote for one of the two main parties are totally disillusioned, Entwistle said.

“Both parties are offering stale policies and this is something different,” he said.

Entwistle believes he’ll do well against B.C. Liberal incumbent Linda Larson in the centre of the riding and against NDP challenger Colleen Ross in places like Grand Forks and Princeton.

“I think in a way both of them are splitting my vote rather than me splitting their votes,” he said, dismissing the concerns of some that by pulling votes away from Ross, he’ll help to re-elect Larson.

Entwistle said his decision to run came when he attended candidates’ forums in Oliver and Okanagan Falls and heard Larson and Ross speaking on healthcare issues.

“I was really appalled by what I heard,” said Entwistle. “That made me feel that I had to do something … I don’t think either of them had a great understanding of what was going on. The solutions they were offering were basically they were reading what their party manifesto was. It blew me away how superficial their answers were.”

Entwistle says all patients should have a regular physician.

“It wouldn’t be that hard to jog the system to make that happen,” he said. “It’s just that people don’t think differently. They just want to carry on doing the same things they’ve been doing before, but the system can be changed relatively easily to put the incentives in for physicians to take on extra patients.”

Having worked in healthcare administration both in the United Kingdom and Canada, as well as setting up a walk-in clinic in New Zealand, Entwistle said he has knowledge of different systems and has ideas about what works and what doesn’t.

Asked about what kind of voice an independent MLA could have in a legislature dominated by a government setting the agenda and an official opposition responding to it, Entwistle gives the example of independent MLA Vicki Huntington.

In 2009, she was the first MLA elected as an independent in B.C. since 1949 and she was re-elected in 2013.

“An independent MLA has way more opportunity than a backbench MLA,” he said. “Backbenchers are tied by party politics and have no voice.”

Government MLAs are tied to the government’s position, he said, pointing to MLA Larson, who he says is supporting bed closures at the Oliver hospital. (Larson insists that there’s no change in the number of funded beds and that they’re just being “reconfigured.”)

“That can’t be good for our community, but that’s what she’s doing,” Entwistle said. “So I think an independent MLA is probably the only way and every riding should have one.”

Entwistle reiterated his previous statement that he would continue to run his medical practice while serving as an MLA and said there are other doctors in the Legislature.

He pointed out that he has already resigned as chief of staff at SOGH, so only has his family practice, and he takes issue with the idea that being MLA is a full-time job.

“I suppose it depends on your definition of a full-time job,” said Entwistle. “My work in the last few years has been on average between 80 and 100 hours a week. MLAs, I’ve seen the hours they work and it’s difficult to see that I couldn’t fit in that while giving up my chief of staff role.”

Entwistle grew up in Southport, England, between Liverpool and Preston, and he did medical schooling in Dundee Scotland. He practiced in New Zealand before returning as a general practitioner to Southport for 30 years.

He came directly to Oliver when he first immigrated to Canada in 2007, but he’s worked as a doctor in Princeton and Keremeos as well.

He says he loves the Okanagan Valley and also knows other parts of Boundary-Similkameen.

“Other candidates would say you don’t understand a place unless you’re three generations in,” he said. “I guess I would beg to differ on that one.”


Osoyoos Times


Print Friendly


  1. Kell Petersen

    April 28, 2017 at 1:28 am

    Dr. Entwistle initiative a worthy cause the problem is the issues discussed on request my input to the Select Standing Committee on Health link attached – the silence is deafening.

    “Good health is the consequence, in the first instance, of investment by the society in research and education that produces businesses that distribute wealth in society by providing better-trained and better-paid employment; a thriving economy has the resources to provide good healthcare, environmental services, and also clean air and water. Resources cannot be allocated in one direction, as to health care for example, without affecting other societal interests that have their own claims to the public purse. Good health is the outcome of many factors, both economic and social. You can’t beggar Peter to pay Paul without paying, in some instances, a larger price down the road. It would be very easy to spend B.C.’s entire stream of revenue on healthcare if we utilized US spending models. Why not apply 17% of GDP to healthcare, as the United States does? Perhaps because it would consume roughly plus 40 billion dollars here, leaving barely enough money to fill in any but the smallest of potholes in our roads, let alone providing for any other public services. The focus must be on the excess consumption of health care private or public on the expenses of the factors that creates and maintain good health in society” –however there is no sign it will changes. The silence from politicians the local MLA and MP and as it seem complacency in the BC and Canadian society to issues that really matter to society is deafening –them who address the problem is out of luck a set up to fail. Gothenburg Sweden April 28, 2017. Kell Petersen

  2. Rick Deis

    April 29, 2017 at 6:03 pm

    Good Luck Dr. Entwistle you have our vote.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *